High Priest Innocentin:
Splendid! Please go to the Pagan Temple and defeat the evil ones that inhabit it! After you've destroyed them, bring me their Pagan Totems. You'll be well-rewarded if you bring more than 2000 of them! Of course, our definitions of large rewards might differ...
As you must have guessed, the Pagan Temple is heavily defended and will not be easily overtaken. Priest Eliyah could give you guidance on how to penetrate their defenses.